London's chamber of commerce wants tax-free apprenticeships, no employer National Insurance on under-25s and half-price fares for young Londoners.
Apprenticeships would be tax-free, employers would pay no National Insurance on staff under 25 and every Londoner under 25 would get half-price fares, under a plan published on Thursday 12 November by the London Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI).
The chamber wants the Government to set up a NEET Taskforce, modelled on the COVID Vaccine Taskforce, to get more young people who are not in employment, education or training into work. It says the taskforce should be led by a business leader, report directly to the Prime Minister and aim to halve the number of NEET young people by 2030, which it says would save at least £11 billion a year.
The report, Back Young People, Back Growth: Fixing the Social Contract, came out ahead of Alan Milburn’s final review of youth unemployment, which the chamber responded to on the night of Monday 16 November.
The chamber’s verdict on the final Milburn review
The final review sets a ten-year ambition to cut the share of young people who are NEET from 13 per cent to around 5 per cent by 2036. The LCCI says that is the right goal, but warns the review will not bring the number down unless the cost of hiring a young person falls, and that its proposals “fail to address the cost crisis at the heart of the issue”.
The chamber wants the Government to answer the review by:
- Removing employer National Insurance for every worker under 25, saving a business £3,000 a year on a £25,000 salary.
- Raising the Employment Allowance to £15,000 for businesses that take on an under-25.
- Making apprenticeships tax-free, with no income tax or employee National Insurance for apprentices and no employer National Insurance for apprentices of any age.
Mr Fatehi said: “Alan Milburn is right to say Britain needs a fundamental reset to tackle youth unemployment, and reducing the number of young people who are NEET from 13 per cent to around 5 per cent by 2036 is the right goal. But the Government cannot spend another decade creating new services, targets and schemes while not addressing the reason businesses are holding back from hiring.
“Employers are willing to give young people a chance, with our research showing that 61 per cent would hire someone with no work history. What they need is a Government who makes hiring affordable and viable. That means cutting employer National Insurance, making apprenticeships tax-free and reducing the wider barriers to taking people on.”
In a further statement on Tuesday 17 November, Mr Fatehi said ministers should not choose between the review’s proposals:
“The Government must accept all of Milburn’s recommendations, including reducing the cost of hiring a young person for businesses. It cannot pick and choose which recommendations it supports if we are going to reach the target of reducing NEETs to 5% which Milburn rightly sets out.
“Reducing the cost of hiring for employers is the quickest and most immediate way we can help those young people who are currently NEET. It does not require legislation and is the only way we can start tackling the NEET crisis before the end of this Parliament. No Government can subsidise a million young people back into work.”
Aaron Walker, the chamber’s head of policy, said: “Employers want to hire and young people want to work. Moving young people from one form of welfare to another or reducing eligibility for certain benefits overlooks the issue at the heart of this crisis: businesses cannot afford to hire.
“Milburn is right to say that we will need to invest upfront to tackle the NEET crisis, but this needs to be investment targeted at meaningfully reducing the cost of employing a young person, increasing the number of apprenticeships to give employers the skills they need to grow, and giving young people access to high-quality education routes leading to a job.
“Without reducing employment costs, Milburn’s recommendations will not deliver fewer NEETs, reduce the cost of the system to the taxpayer, or achieve better outcomes for the young people we are failing.”
What it means in Havering
In September, 1,440 Havering residents aged 16 to 24 were claiming benefits mainly because they were out of work, up 95 in a month and 145 in a year, the sharpest rise of any age group, as we reported in October.
Two of the chamber’s proposals would land directly on Havering’s young workers and the firms that employ them:
- A Youth Oyster, giving every Londoner under 25 and every apprentice half-price fares. Outside London, the chamber wants a tax-free Commute to Work scheme for under-35s, with unlimited travel within a region for £80 a month.
- No employer National Insurance for any worker under 25, which the LCCI says would save an employer £3,000 a year on a £25,000 salary.
In the chamber’s own survey, 74% of London employers said the cost of housing harms their ability to recruit and keep staff, and 51% said the same of transport costs.
The report also says LCCI data shows 90% of London firms did not try to recruit for two quarters in a row.
What employers told YouGov
The LCCI commissioned two YouGov surveys, carried out online from 12 to 25 August 2026: 1,039 UK adults aged 24 to 35 and 509 UK employers. The figures are weighted to be representative.
- 53% of employers are more likely to hire someone with a completed apprenticeship than someone without one; 45% say the same of a university degree.
- Among small firms the gap is twice as wide: 43% for an apprenticeship against 21% for a degree. Among manufacturers, 75% favour a completed apprenticeship.
- 61% of employers would hire a young person with no work history at all.
- 58% say removing employer National Insurance for under-25s would help their business.
- Among employers that tried to recruit, 37% named the cost of employer National Insurance as one of their main challenges.
- Just 7% say young people arrive with all the skills their business needs; 38% say they arrive with few or none, and 48% say schools and universities do not equip people for work.
What young people said
- 90% of 24 to 35-year-olds said it is better to have a job than not, and 74% of young employees said they are motivated to win a promotion.
- 59% of young workers say they pay too much income tax, rising to 68% of those earning £45,000 to £69,999.
- 67% say their Council Tax is too high, more than for any other tax they were asked about.
- 54% say stamp duty is too high, rising to 71% among those earning £45,000 to £69,999.
- 73% of those with a student loan earning £45,000 to £69,999 say their repayments are too high.
- Half of young workers earning £45,000 or more say benefits are too high, as do 44% of the young self-employed.
The apprenticeship gap
The report says 125,000 more young people go to university each year than start an apprenticeship, and that the gap is five times wider than it was in 2006. For every young person who starts an apprenticeship, nearly three still go to university, and graduates take on an average of £47,900 of debt, the chamber says. One in three apprenticeships is never completed.
To change that, the LCCI wants the Government to:
- Make apprenticeships tax-free for employers and apprentices. An apprentice aged 22 on £20,000 would keep £2,080 a year more, and an employer would save £2,250 a year on an apprentice aged 25 or over.
- Pay a £3,000 Completion Bonus into a first home ISA when an apprentice finishes their first apprenticeship, with a matching £3,000 for employers who keep them on for 12 months.
- Create Apprenticeship+, with one day a week at university, so apprentices learn higher education skills without the debt of a three-year degree.
- Start Junior Apprenticeships from Year 10, alongside a new Employment Skills GCSE.
- Run a Great British Apprenticeship Campaign to raise the status of apprenticeships, plus a new Entrepreneur Apprenticeship.
- Cap out-of-work benefits for under-25s at 12 months, after which every young person would move onto a paid apprenticeship funded by the Government and delivered by mayors or local councils.
Tax, homes and families
The wider package aims at what the chamber calls a broken social contract, “the idea that if you work hard you’ll get on and succeed in life”. It proposes:
- a tax-free threshold of £18,000 for everyone under 35, worth £1,100 a year;
- a Starting a Family ISA with a 25% government top-up for each parent, and the Tax-Free Childcare cap doubled to £4,000 per child;
- letting first-time buyers put their pension contributions towards a deposit, and a London Mortgage at six times income, with rent paid on time counted in every mortgage application;
- abolishing interest on student loans and cutting repayments from 9% to 3%. The chamber says a Plan 2 graduate earning £51,000 loses 51p of every extra pound, against 47p for a millionaire.
By the LCCI’s sums, an apprentice aged 22 on £20,000 would be £3,110 a year better off from paying no income tax or National Insurance and having a half-price Youth Oyster, and would get £3,000 towards a first home on qualifying. A London business with ten staff, three of them aged 21 to 24 and one an apprentice aged 25 or over, would cut its employer National Insurance bill by more than two-thirds, saving £15,750 a year. A firm with ten staff aged 21 to 24 on £25,000 would save £34,500 a year.
The chamber would pay for it by replacing the pensions triple lock with an Earnings Guarantee, halving the number of NEET young people, getting 50,000 more young people a year into apprenticeships instead of university, means-testing free travel for pensioners and bringing the working-age sickness benefits bill back to 2021-22 levels. It says that would save £26 billion in the second year and £38 billion in the third.
“The same urgency we gave the pandemic”
Karim Fatehi OBE, chief executive of the LCCI, said: “Businesses are telling us loud and clear that they value completed apprenticeships, and that they are willing to take a chance on young people with no work history at all. What is holding them back is the cost of taking anyone on.
“The NEET crisis deserves the same urgency we gave the pandemic. If the Government is serious about getting young people into work, it has to back the businesses that will employ them, by cutting the cost of hiring and making apprenticeships tax-free.”
Aaron Walker, the chamber’s head of policy and public affairs, said: “If the Government responds to the NEET crisis with minor tweaks to the edges of the apprenticeship, welfare and education systems, without the fundamental and radical reform we badly need, or without lowering the cost of hiring and the cost of doing business, the Milburn review will fail.
“No Government can subsidise a million young people back into work. The answer to the £125 billion a year NEET crisis can only come from giving businesses the backing they need to hire and grow. If businesses cannot grow, the economy cannot grow.
“There is not a single person in the country today who benefits from a less wealthy, less successful and less prosperous next generation. Young people themselves suffer, businesses suffer, and wider society suffers. If today’s young people are at risk of becoming the first generation to be worse off than their parents, then the next generation to retire are at risk of having a worse retirement than their parents. If we back our young people, we will back growth.”
The £125 billion figure is the yearly cost to the economy found by Milburn’s interim review, the report says, which also found the number of NEET young people had risen by almost 140,000 in a decade.
“No Government can subsidise a million young people”
On Sunday 15 November, responding to Pat McFadden’s interview with David Olusoga on Sky News Sunday Morning, Mr Fatehi said the Government’s “fundamental reset” had to start with the cost of hiring.
“The Government will not tackle the NEET crisis while continuing to make it more difficult and more expensive for businesses to employ people,” he said.
“The fundamental reset Pat McFadden has described must include reducing hiring costs and ensuring our education system gives young people the skills businesses need, rather than tweaks to the edges of the welfare system.
“The Milburn review risks repeating the failures of previous governments if it overlooks who is at the centre of the solution: the employers and entrepreneurs who actually create jobs. Businesses are willing to give young people a chance, but rising costs are making it harder to hire each person.
“Extending The Jobs Guarantee Scheme is a start, but it would only help just 10% of those who are NEET by 2029. No Government can subsidise a million young people back into work.”
The LCCI represents a network of 12,000 London businesses, from microbusinesses to major corporations. More on its work is at londonchamber.co.uk.
Source: London Chamber of Commerce and Industry.
Have your say